Lost at Birth

(Review of Ch.10 CE Part 1) This is another one of those AVNs where you can pick between corrupting or showing your care for the LIs, which theoretically will lead to different outcomes. That said, I haven't yet put that to the test and I'm not sure I ever will because there's something fundamentally wrong here. Two things actually. First is the stiff characters. About 97% of renders with an LI in the frame show them with the same poker face, like they're robots. I can count with a single hand the number of times a character looks at you in the eye or appears to show a human emotion. This makes it really hard to feel involved in the story other than the basic interest to get to the lewds, which negates the point of an AVN in the first place; you could as well fap to any of the millions of porn videos out there and carry on with your life. Don't even think of downloading this for a quick fap. Second is the anticlimatic scenes. One click too many and the animation is over, the rest are just stills, sorry! I mean, there's only a bunch of animations (certainly a tiny fraction of what I'd expect) and you will have to be patient to get to something worth fapping to. Sure, the visuals are nice, your daughter's ass is divine and yadda yadda, but (a) audio support could be axed as it is totally ineffective and (b) the models are wasted for the most part because the real juicy bits you'll be forced to imagine them yourself. Suddenly Honey Select and its clones don't look so bad in comparison. Heck, even a modded Fallout 4 can beat this. Is it garbage? No, but for an AVN that claims to be at Ch. 10 I was expecting this to be so much better.

The plot of this game and the developers script writing ability have really done it a disservice. I don't know how this game manages to rush every scene while simultaneously going nowhere with the plot for 10 chapters. Pros: - Incredible visuals and animations - Ch 1-3 feel like the start of a good story - Character models are fresh Cons: -Story goes nowhere for 10 chapters. The same conflict has been going on for multiple chapters with no forward progress -Developer gives options for choices and they basically don't matter - The wife is written as if she's supposed to be crazy and naggy but she's incredibly nice and the MC is gaslighting her while fucking his daughter. And you (as a player) have no choice as to how this dynamic unfolds -Bad pacing.Really bad

So great I love the animations and models in this and it's great for replayability can't wait to play more potentially! Would be great to see more from this developer and these lovable characters and continue playing the great story!!!

Wow nothing gets more turned on with a multiple choice game than one that simply lies about the multiple choice. Yeah you heard me, this thing pretends you're making some diff impact with each pop up but in reality its a lie. I turned the daughter down EVERY single time yet somehow we end up fucking anyway. Oh okay guess I'll just go fuck myself, the game has a mind of its own and I'm just along for the ride. Its even funnier when the MC is like "Oh we gotta stop doing this" then 5 mins later hes balls deep in her mouth again.. Edit - At this point I'm skipping through it all.. the "caring" trait is no longer an option .. I can either have a mindset of "My daughter sent me a nude I love that." or "My daughter sent me a nude I'm gonna drill her." No rational thinking here chief move on.

Quality of animation is good, characters are nicely done. Tried after a long time again a storyline with father and daughter and got reconfirmed, this is not a storyline I really enjoy. So the core decision for other viewers of the novel is simply, are you into this or not. If you are, you might rate the novel a bit higher, especially as there is not only father/daughter but many more ladies available for the male MC. I personally will not follow up.

Don't believe the Rating, this game definitely has not earned it. Pros - - High quality character models and renders. All the characters are attractive and well proportioned. The scenes are well lit and don't have that dollhouse effect that many do. - The animations are good especially the deformation so it doesn't look like Mc's dick is just clipping into the girls, but they're just a second or two looped with a little camera movement. Cons - - The writing is absolutely awful. The Author only writes dialogue with absolutely no narration or set dressing whatsoever . Everything feels extremely rushed, and whats happening in the renders is often not reflected in the dialogue at all. For instance, Kailey shows absolutely no reaction to man she just met, that might be her father, suddenly caressing her face or putting his hand on her thigh. -There is also the MC's justification for cheating on his wife, claiming he is in a "loveless marriage." which is absolutely not in any way depicted by the actual scenes. Justine may have a drinking problem, but she very clearly behaves as if she loves the MC, even obsessively so. She is constantly seeking his attention and affection, and seems like she would happily bend over a shopping cart in the middle of a busy supermarket for him if he asked. She is in no way denying him sex other than falling asleep after an orgasm, if MC knows that happens with her he could easily just stop getting her off before sex or making sure not to leave time for her to fall asleep. Despite her overwhelming willingness, he's actively seeking sex from other sources instead. In fact in most scenes with her she is actively seeking intimacy from the MC which he either passively goes along with or even seems to resist in some cases. He's not in a loveless marriage at all, he just doesn't love his wife enough to make a real effort for her and would rather fuck anyone he can get his hands on. - The Characters lack depth. Likely due to the authors refusal to describe the scene or the events going on through anything other than still images and dialogue, everyone feels fairly flat. The dialogue itself is fine, I guess, but not nearly enough to bring any life into the "story." - The illusion of choice. I'm fine with Kinetic Novels, and I generally prefer when regardless of your choices, you can still get all available scenes unless you choose to opt out, but I don't like fake choices that do absolutely nothing whatsoever. While some of the choices in this game do affect a bit of dialogue, or result in skipping a scene, that is the extent of their impact. They have no bearing at all on the story outside of that particular moment. - Why the fuck is everyone so god damn touchy? What accountant sits there holding hands with his boss, or letting her touch his chest, or putting their hands on each other's shoulders? Why is absolutely no attention ever called to how much the characters touch each other? At the end of the day, if you want to skip all the dialogue and goon to some good quality 3D models, you'll enjoy this. If you care at all about a good story, skip it.

This VN has beautiful renders, hot and erotic H-animations with sounds. The main LI shines. This VN has the best F/D scenes in any VN I have played. If you are into Father-Daughter incest, i would highly recommend you play this!

If V19 ever finishes his great game, which I doubt a little at this point, I will be delighted. I have offered to integrate my handmade German translation into his updates in order to reach a wider audience. I still hope that this will happen.

Really hard to rate this game. As a game, it gets 2 stars for a critical bug I see in PenPy game for the 1st time. There are no saves. Well technically there are, but you can not load them. So be ready to complete your walkthrough in 1 go, or skip till the moment you stopped on. Depending on choices we are getting some stats, but not sure if those are changing anything. Your possible LIs pool is small, there are hints it might be bigger, but most of the content is with your daughter. From novel POV - 3 stars. Characters development, plot progression pace, dialogues and overall tone -- if any of those are critical for you, the game might be not to your liking. Techical part tho (omitting the save situation fuckup) is 5/5. Renders are extremely well made, animations are superb, physics and sounds are included. Creator for sure knows how to place the camera for giving the most impressive vews and perspective. NSFW scenes are pretty vanilla. The main kink all the content revolves about is romancing the blonde on the title pic, who might or might not be MCs daughter. If thats your kink, your rating probably will be higher

When I started playing this I had hope for some nice romance game focused on father - daughter relationship. I'm not disappointed. Plot is very simple and game is quite short as for over 3,5 years old one. You focus on your daughter, wife and few other LIs (optionally(?)). Don't expect any deep storytelling, mysteries, plot twists or anything original. Just a simple game with some decisions. Decisions however (at least for now, Ch. 10, Part 1) almost don't mean anything. You're manouvering between decisions that walkthrough describe as caring/love/corruption, later comes domination/cautious in work, but for now it change literally nothing, but denying other LIs. MC's going to have sex with daughter anyway (will just feel better or worse after sex) and by denying other LIs you're just skipping scene, because next time you'll still have possibility to fuck Cass and I guess Alice option is still on table after she's denied . Plot even being simple, is nice to read. It's just you and relationships. A refreshing change after games focused mostly on plot. What's worth noting here? Characters. They're god damn gorgeous. Amazing body proportions without overwhelming breats and with beautiful faces. They look just proper for their age and especially older ones are extremelly well-groomed and classy. Some devs want older LIs to look average, but here you won't find this. Here you'll find digital copies of the best looking women for their age. Especially Cassidy, she's top tier. Their characters also fit roles, some of them are friendly other kinky, pushy or have mood swifts. Character building is definetely a big con of this game. It's 4/5 for now, but after few updates, when story develops and choices will (hopefully) have some affection on game, it may be strong 5/5 game.

Pretty great game. The beginning was really boring, just a slide show of pictures and dialogue, The story was really cheesy but good in the beginning, It was enough to keep me interested. As the game progressed the scenes began to get more detailed and animated. Far from standard but a major step up from chapter 1-3. I really felt bad for the wife. In the beginning you could sort of justify it with loneliness, as terrible of an excuse as that is, but once the story progress it becomes harder and harder to justify. I really wanted the Wife and Daughter to be okay with each other as a love triangle but it never really progressed that way and ended suddenly. I think a polygamous relationship between the 3 would've made a lot of sense. However the only thing I saw standing in the way of that is Jealousy of each other. I do think the daughter has the potential to be a surrogate, however the MC possibly impregnates everyone he speaks to. The renders were beautiful, I especially loved the look of the wife and daughter. So beautiful! The anatomy was also really well designed. My biggest complaint was that it was mostly a slideshow.

Saves don't work period - that alone gives one star. It's a bit overly wordy, too. Unless you think you can play through this game in one sitting or just leave it open all the time until done, it's not going to be worth even trying.

its a Great Game. Animation is good. Models are Fantastic and Unique. I glad you are able to skip days if needed as it cut down on unnecessary time. I'm love all their personalities and how they are all different

All right I am just going to flat out say it like it is. This is really a kinetic novel with fake choices sprink;ed in to make you think you have the power to influence anything in it. Don't believe me? Play through it. Make your decisions just like you would want to make them. Then once done, Oh yeah, don't try reloading as all the save files I made came up as corrupt/incompatable which made them just a pretty picture instead of useful. Once done. Go to menu and select a chapter. Now skip and change the choices you made as you go along. Just keep skipping. You can because not a damn thing changes anywhere in the game as nothing you choose mean s jack. Oh and lets talk about the fact this is a cum as you please game with no consequences as well. It tries to pretend like it matters where you cum but lets be real, you see a pregnancy tag? Nah I didn't see one either. So the should I mention a morning after a pill is just further proof of how little cjoices mean in this. I gave this a 3 simply due to the great sex animations and the good looking women. The story is pure crapola. You are fucking around on me. Ummm, but you are my daughter. Ok well don't do it anymore and you can keep fucking me. Ok baby. But my wife is at home so I am still gonna fuck her too. Ok daddy. Garbage! Nothing you do matters so just do what it lets you do anyway.

After a year of nothing it finally updates with nothing. Why this doesn't have an abandoned tag is beyond me. The game's plot literally has not progressed since the last update and the lewd content is still practically the same with nothing noteworthy being added. It isn't going to get finished at all not even halfway for that matter. 2/5

I am not sure what's up with this 2 and 3 stars rating, but in my hamble opinion this is a great game. Hot base idea and super hot women and sex scenes. I think it is easy on the top 20% ... 5/5 It doesn't have a lot of content yet, but hopefully it will expand. Hope the developer keeps developing, looking forward for the next version.

[Ch. 9 CE Part 2] > Nice graphics: blur, focus, clarity, fidelity, exposition, post-processing - everything is well-done. > Very erotic and sensual teasing/sex with decent animations and sound effects, tho scenes before ch. 4-5 are short and not animated. > Not a slow-burn, your relationship with estranged daughter progresses with lightning speed. Other relationships make very little sense either, like your boss suddenly having hots for you, or random teen wanting you to be her first. > Pretty much kinetic. Sure you can skip some sex scenes but that's it. I've tried multiple routes and outcomes were almost the same. Like, for example, it doesn't matter if you have affairs or not, Kailey will still throw a fit about cheating and protag still feels like shit, even if he done nothing wrong. > Takes about 2 hours to finish, no ending or conclusion of course, cause abandoned. A real shame, there was potential. Nevermind, lol, just god updated. ★★★☆☆ pretty much for the lack of content, otherwise would be higher.

It is high quality AVN that could be great if it was not just written as a simple incest porn fantasy. Graphics are great, character models are very well done, lewd scenes are good, music fits the avn genre. So far so good you say? Why is it only 3 stars? Because writting is subpar at best. Started strong simple enough setting, introducing MC and side characters. Mc is toubled by his boring marriage. He comes Kailey, your shy and innocent new found daughter. Still fine right ? Yeah but from chapter 4 author gave up on treating this game as multichoice novel. You have to have sex with your daughter (forced) you have to cheat on your wife who sleeps in the next room ,with your daughter. I liked some semblance of morality system that was in first few chapters (tried to play kinda decent human being) but it does not even matter. Dont try and play as anything other than cheating degenerate. Mc is horrible. Dude got seduced by virgin teenager, no selfcontrol whatsoever. Tries to act as an adult but is written as a pathetic excuse fo human being (just to push incest story). Kailey truns 180 from being innocent girl to just sex depraved fiend in one chapter (4-5). She seduced grown as man and tries to cheat with him on every possible step. But yeah. If you want something to add to your spankbank, Lost at Brith is game for you. If you looking for something with story that makes sence and characters that resemble ateast to some degree real people behaviour + game where chooices matter. Just save your time and avoid it.

Good Points + Visually the game looks good. + Even tho designs of tits looks bad, weirdly enough this game has one of best pussy design I have ever seen. + Sex scenes from chapter 3 has animations with couple different positions/angles and they are quite decent. + MC's and Kailey's relationship felt rushed and off sometimes, but it was kind of enjoyable as well. Bad Points - Choices doesn't really matter, in the end certain main events still happen like Cassidy and MC having talk about Kailey or things happened with Kailey still happening, etc. - Most of love interests and characters are not likeable. They are either straight up sluts with no self-reflection at all like Cassidy, like seriously doing all that stuff, taking MC to BDSM room to have sex while Kailey seeing it, then blaming MC for it and saying she has no fault at all, he is shift blaming her or very selfish people like MC's wife, there is literally nothing likeable about her, especially how dumb she is and tauntrums she is constantly doing, saying nonsense stuff like ''I feel like I'm the only one caring about this marriage'' meanwhile she is literally the one ruined the whole marriage and reason for MC cheating on her, etc, is quite annoying, not to say she treated a girl who nees shelter shitty AF and literally almost drunk AF, and literally knows nothing about his own husband, like saying he is lazy because MC sleeping until noon, meanwhile he was working hard AF at job and having very bad time, he slept until noon because he is exhausted, not to forget he is the one who doing cooking in the home as well, of course he is tired... Considering how bad most love interests are it would be logical if MC given choice to divorce his wife, not get involved with other girls like not becoming even a friend with Cassidy since she is involved with MC's relationship with Kailey no matter you do and MC start a life with Kailey alone, or have a option to be dominant, but not have sexual thing going on with Leianii, etc, could be game changer and fix a lot of stuff for sure. - Certain things makes no sense at all like MC asking advice from Cassidy for his daughter and his relationship, letting her know something she shouldn't, she getting involved in their relationship and even trying to make her work as a bartender in a erotic nightclub, etc, without even MC or players having zero saying in it... - Story felt promissing at first, but sadly writing of dialogues and scenes feels bit off and bit weak. - Every Renpy game out there has 999+ save page, it's not something hard, pretty easy, and normal. But tis game has only 24 save page, it had 11 before, but developer seems decided add 13 more... At this point it's not even funny... - Designs of the tits needs change, nearly every women in the game has kind of saggy, small and low quality looking tits, more round, bit bigger and better quality tits designs could be game changer. - Some features not works as intended or bugged, like animations and walkthrough built in, there are settings in the menu to make them ''on'' but making them ''on'' actually makes them off and you can't change back later either, for that you need to delete your persistent file in Renpy save location so your settings will reset. - First three chapter is not animated, and even tho sex animations are mostly good, since the DEV trying not to show MC's face positions mostly ends up being either too close or kind of weird, third person not too close animations would be good if DEV can stop weird obsession not to show MC's face. For The End Well, this is not a bad game, but does nothing special either and has a lot of problem and lack of feature going on, I was waiting some of issues fixed with Ch. 10, but almost nothing fixed, so I will be dropping my rate from 3 stars to 2 stars instead.

[Ch 9 CE Part 2] Sadly one of the biggest disappointments I had in a long while... In terms of quality it is awesome. Renders are perfect, the world, scenery, characters, sex scenes, everything is just right. In terms of story and gameplay? So fucking dissapointing... Game from the start gives player ilussion of choice and then hits player's head with a brick of reality. It doesn't really matter if you choose to be perverted or carying father because at the end you will be forced to have sex with your (probably) daugher multiple times anyway. It also doesn't matter if you will be dominant or submissive, you will get promoted and forced to fuck your boss anyway. It is so fucking annoying, the thing I hate most in AVNs is illusion of choice. Because of dev's failing to make decissions meaningful, MC looks like beta who does the opposite of what he wants/thinks or does what others tell him. He spams with thoughts like "oh, I will not do this or that because it is not right" but on next scene he does the opposite, already fingering/kissing/gropping/fucking Kailey, what is the point of that? Same goes with his female boss, at the end of a day he is submissive and plays her game anyway. His relation with wife is also annoying as fuck, he knows how bad heavy drinking is yet he allows her to do it. Meanwhile he tells everyone how unhappy he is, spams thoughts about how bad her drinking is and when he opens his mouth to say something, all he can say is "yes hun, of course hun, love you hun" and basically allowing her to push him around. The worst thing is that, as I said, quality is really great even including dialogues (quality-wise, not content-wise) so the story and false sense of the importance of made decisions dissapoints even more. There are tons of shitty games in here and I couldn't care less, I'm mad when I see game with great potential wasted.